Idaho’s BoiseThe lawyers for Bryan Kohberger had taken every precaution to keep him alive.
On a number of grounds, including that it would be against international law or standards of decency, that prosecutors had not adequately presented evidence, and that their client’s autism diagnosis diminished any potential responsibility, they attempted to prevent prosecutors from pursuing the death penalty in the stabbing deaths of four University of Idaho students.
They contested the validity of DNA evidence and asked for authorization to tell a jury that someone else was responsible for the crime.
It didn’t work. A plea agreement to escape death was their last resort, as Kohberger’s trial for the quadruple murder was scheduled to start next month.
Kohberger, 30, is scheduled to appear before Idaho Fourth Judicial District Judge Steven Hippler in Boise on Wednesday at 11 a.m. MDT. He is anticipated to enter a guilty plea to charges of killing Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, and Xana Kernodle at a rental house close to the Moscow, Idaho, campus early on November 13, 2022.
According to prosecutors’ letter to the families, which ABC News cited, “This resolution is our sincere attempt to seek justice for your family.” The offender will be found guilty, imprisoned for the remainder of his life, and unable to subject you and the other families to the uncertainty of decades of post-conviction appeals, thanks to this deal.”
Families of the victims respond in different ways.
According to their spokesperson, Christina Teves, the family of Chapinone, who had three triplets who went to the same university, is in favor of the agreement. Mogen’s mother and stepfather’s lawyer, Leander James, said he will make a statement on their behalf following Wednesday’s hearing but declined to share their opinions. Ben Mogen, Mogen’s father, expressed his relief at the arrangement to CBS News.
He remarked, “We can truly move on from this and avoid these future dates and events that we don’t want to be at, that we shouldn’t have to be at, that have to do with this awful person.” All we have to do is consider the remainder of our life and attempt to figure out how to live without Maddie and the other children.
However, it infuriated the Goncalves family, who took to Facebook to express their disapproval of the agreement and to call on any people who feel inspired or motivated to try to change things to get in touch with the Ada County Courthouse.
The Goncalves family stated on Monday, “We are absolutely incensed at the State of Idaho.” They have let us down.
“We stand strong that it is not over until a plea is accepted,” they wrote in another post on Tuesday. We will continue to battle for the life that was wrongfully taken. Please, at the at least, demand a complete confession, complete responsibility, the whereabouts of the murder weapon, proof that the defendant acted alone, and the actual circumstances of what transpired that evening. We have a right to know when the end was approaching.
The family expressed their strong opposition to a plea agreement in a conversation with the prosecution on Friday. After sending us a frantic email on Sunday, they met with the prosecution once more on Monday to discuss their position on advocating for the death penalty.
Despite being sentenced to life in jail, Bryan Kohberger would still be able to communicate, build connections, and interact with the outside world. Aubrie, the 18-year-old sister of Kaylee Goncalves, wrote. Our loved ones, meanwhile, have been permanently silenced. When it seems that the system is more concerned with safeguarding his future than with respecting the victims’ pasts, that fact hurts even more.
The judge has to approve the plea deal.
Although they are uncommon, judges in Idaho have the authority to reject plea deals. Kohberger would probably be sentenced in late July if he enters the anticipated guilty plea on Wednesday. After pretrial publicity in remote northern Idaho, his trial was transferred to Boise, where it is scheduled for August.
Kohberger was a graduate student studying criminal justice at Washington State University, which is located roughly 9 miles (14.5 kilometers) west of the University of Idaho, during the time of the murders. Weeks later, he was arrested in his parents’ home state of Pennsylvania. His DNA, according to investigators, was linked to genetic material taken from a knife sheath that was discovered at the scene of the crime.
According to autopsies, the four victims were most likely asleep at the time of the assault. Each was stabbed several times, and some suffered defensive wounds. According to online buying records, Kohberger had bought a military-style knife and a sheath similar to the one discovered at the scene months prior.
The killings’ motive has not been revealed.
The murders have no known motivation, and it’s unclear why the assailant killed the two roommates who were present. According to authorities, Kohberger made at least a dozen trips to the victims’ neighborhood before to the murders, as evidenced by security footage and cellular data.
The killings horrified the 25,000-person tiny farming hamlet, which hadn’t seen a homicide in around five years, and led to a huge search for the killer. Using cellphone data to pinpoint Kohberger’s activities the night of the killings, genetic genealogy to identify him as a potential suspect, and a complex search for a white automobile that was seen on surveillance cameras going past the rental house repeatedly were all part of this.
Following the murders, Telisa Swan, who owns a tattoo parlor in Moscow, said the population was “shocked and devastated.”
She remarked, “I have never really locked my doors at night before, and I have ever since.” Although I believe the town is recovering, I don’t think things will ever be the same.
Kohberger’s attorneys claimed in a court document that he was driving alone when the four were slain.
The court dismissed the defense team’s attempt last week to argue during the trial that any one of four other individuals might have committed the crimes, concluding that the evidence presented to bolster that theory was completely unrelated.
Nothing connects these people to the killings or suggests in any other way that they were responsible for the crimes; in fact, Hippler stated that the jury would need to engage in nothing less than irrational conjecture to reach this conclusion.
___
From Seattle, Johnson reported.
