Flint, Michigan.Jeffrey Bell watched in anticipation that his mother’s home would be the next to be excavated and have its lead water pipes replaced. Employees informed him that it was likely assigned to another contractor but wasn’t on their list.
Bell and his elderly mother were concerned that their shared home would be ignored when Flint’s lead pipe replacement program came to an end this year. Betty Bell, who had been purchasing bottled drinking water for years, called the city several times. Records show that the water line was checked in 2017, but at last someone called to claim everything was fine. The Bells, however, were unaware of that, illustrating the residents’ perplexity over a procedure tainted by hold-ups and inadequate communication.
Jeffrey Bell stated, “I have even more questions now.”
Lead water pipe replacement is still ongoing almost ten years after Flint’s water crisis sparked national outcry. The deal did not include abandoned homes and permitted owners to refuse, potentially leaving hundreds of pipes in the ground, even though the city recently claimed to have finished the work mandated by a court judgment. The state says it is committed to completing the repairs on those properties by the fall and pledged to supervise it.
Municipalities facing a recent federal obligation to replace their own lead service lines can learn from Flint’s mistakes. It is anticipated that the Trump administration will shortly inform a federal appeals court of its intention to uphold that mandate.
Margie Kelly, a spokesman for the environmental charity Natural Resources Defense Council, which came to an agreement with the city to compel it to repair lead pipes, said, “I think other cities are racing not to be Flint.”
Flint stumbles.
In order to save money, a state-appointed emergency manager terminated a contract with Detroit’s water system in 2014 and moved to the Flint River, which sparked the city’s problem. However, the state didn’t need to treat the water to stop the corrosion that led to lead leaking into it.
Eventually, high levels of lead were found in children’s blood and drinking water.The city’s water was also partially responsible for outbreaks of Legionnaires’ disease that claimed twelve lives.
Flint signed a settlement in 2017 that mandated it replace all lead pipes and repair excavated yards at no cost within three years. At the NRDC’s request, funds were initially allocated to homes with known lead lines, making it impossible for workers to address communities in a methodical manner. Additionally, it was difficult to locate those residences since a large number of records—some scrawled on notecards from the early 1900s—were either missing or erroneous.
According to Sarah Tallman, an NRDC lawyer, the city’s overall program administration was inefficient and should have better coordinated operations geographically.
This caused the program to slow, and in the end, the city was forced to verify all of the pipes regardless. Work was also slowed by COVID-19.
Kenneth Miller, the director of the Flint Department of Public Works, who was recruited last year, stated that the city was unaware of the number of homeowners who chose not to replace their lead pipes or the number of properties that were overlooked as contractors came and left.
People become lazy, quit doing things, are laid off, and the person who used to do it no longer does it, he said, just like in any other organization.
The city failed to maintain correct records of repairs, so a judge ordered officials to visually inspect thousands of excavated properties.
Contractor-demolished yards occasionally remained that way for months or even years. Danyele Darrough said that her driveway and sidewalk were covered and that her yard had been in disarray for months. Workers’ applied grass seed never grew. After almost three years, she finally purchased bags of topsoil and seed this spring to repair her grass herself.
Darrough responded, “Yeah, we knew it; we couldn’t trust them.”
According to Miller, the city now has a strong data management system, and he advises other cities dealing with lead lines to adopt this approach.
According to Eric Oswald, drinking water director at Michigan’s Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy, contractors will need to seal lead lines when they are found in the thousands of empty homes left by the state’s severe population decline.
“The city and the state wanted to make sure that we do everything possible,” he said.
Trust is essential.
In Flint, an EPA inspector general report found that all levels of government either contributed to the lead situation or postponed its resolution. Nearly 700 Flint homes refused free lead pipe replacement because of the scandal, which weakened public confidence in the government, according to the NRDC.
Last year, Flint finally passed a law that forbids homeowners from choosing to opt out.
According to Oswald, crossing the finish line is quite challenging unless you have something to enforce. In order to facilitate its operations, Benton Harbor, located throughout the state, put in place a similar clause early on.
Officials are currently sending letters and, if necessary, visiting homes in person while working from a list of over 4,000 residences where a lead line may exist. Rebuilding trust will take time, but Miller said he thinks the effort will demonstrate that customer service is now a top focus.
The EPA, which in May revoked a long-standing emergency order for Flint water, is likewise viewed with suspicion by some. Following years of testing that revealed significantly lower levels of lead, the FDA declared that it is now safe to drink from the tap.
At a recent community event, homeowner Aonie Gilcreast stated, “We don’t know what to believe.” Because officials have repeatedly stated that everything was OK, we don’t trust the system.
There are almost 9 million lead pipes in the United States, and as other cities and towns begin rebuilding their own, one thing should be at the forefront of their minds, according to experts: Excavating them is not only a construction task but also a test of community trust.
Workers typically have to excavate in the yard and street and enter the house to replace the lines that connect the street water main to residences. Residents are more inclined to provide access when they have faith in the local administration.
Greg Kail, a spokesman for the utility industry group American Water Works Association, stated that, like everything else, lead cannot be the first thing that customers hear from their water utility. Rather, utilities should inform locals about their plans and involve reputable community organizations in the endeavor.
Newark rushes ahead.
When it came to its own lead crisis, Newark, New Jersey, stayed clear of Flint’s mistakes.
About two years after the elevated levels were made public, and with the money at hand, the mayor declared in 2019 that the city will replace over 20,000 lead pipes within three years at no cost to the citizens. However, a problem quickly surfaced: many of the renters in Newark were unable to authorize the work.
We were unable to enter the homes. Kareem Adeem, the director of water and sewer in Newark, stated, “We were unable to locate the owners.” There, they don’t reside. The lead service line was not something they were interested in maintaining.
Therefore, the city enacted a law requiring the removal of lead pipes and granting renters the authority to authorize the operation.
Then, taking a cue from Flint, contractors proceeded swiftly block by block across the city.
Officials informed the most obstinate residents when replacement work would begin and promised to turn off the water until the resident gave them permission to finish. The danger was sufficient. According to Adeem, they never really had to cut off anyone’s water.
Occasionally, residents would recognize Adeem from television, and he could strike up a discussion that would weaken their resolve to refuse. He also collaborated with reputable community organizations.
And the ruling that guaranteed cleanup of people’s property afterwards? Until the contractors completed the job and repaired any damage, they were not paid in full.
___
The Walton Family Foundation provides funding to the Associated Press to cover environmental and water policies. All content is entirely the AP’s responsibility. Please visit https://apnews.com/hub/climate-and-environment to view all of AP’s environmental coverage.
